Author Archive
Mark McGwire: Hall of Fame or Infamy?
(Originally posted on January 9, 2009)
It’s that time of the year that everyone waits for: the release of the Baseball Hall of Fame ballots! I’m sure everyone has had their calendars marked (since they brought them out 9 days ago) for this coming Monday. (Oh, just me?) The 575 qualified voters have sent in their ballots and the whole world is waiting with bated breath for the results of the tally. There are some usual faces on the list of candidates (Jim Rice, Tommy John, Andre Dawson and Burt Blyleven), several first-time-eligible players (Rickey Henderson, Jay Bell, David Cone and Mark Grace) and one very juice-y, very controversial candidate: Mark McGwire.
There are two things that even the most casual of fans knows about McGwire: he was the first to break Roger Maris’ single-season homerun record, and he was heavily involved in the steroid investigation. If the first fact guaranteed his acceptance into the Hall, then the second seemingly had an equal and opposite effect. Luckily for McGwire, the people that vote on these things are slightly more than casual fans (except for Pedro Gomez).
For those who aren’t extreme baseball enthusiasts, I’ll rundown a quick list of Big Mac’s accomplishments (found here):
- Currently sitting #8 on the all-time home run leaderboard, with Alex Rodriguez lurking a scant 50 bombs behind him (should pass him by the AllStar break, I’m guessing).
- #9 in career Slugging Percentage, slightly higher than such lumber luminaries as Joe DiMaggio, Rogers Hornsby and Albert Belle (ha).
- #11 on the all-time OPS (On base plus Slugging) list, just above other greats like Mickey Mantle and Stan Musial.
- An On base percentage of .3942, which is only good enough for 77th all-time, but still puts him in the same range as HOFers Rod Carew and Joe Morgan.
- Chosen for 12 AllStar teams, finished in the top 10 in MVP voting five times and was awarded the Gold Glove in 1990.
- Led his team to the playoffs 6 times, won a pennant 3 times and capped off the 1989 season with a World Series victory.
The importance of home runs cannot be overstated. Obviously there is more to baseball than just jacking out longballs, but there is nothing more exciting than seeing a baseball disappear over an outfield wall. With a home run, there is one outcome and one outcome only: run(s) scored; and since this isn’t golf, that’s a good thing. So, you’d have to imagine that when someone does that at a pace more prolific than 99.9% of the people who have attempted it before him, it would only seem appropriate to honor him with induction into the HOF, right?
OBP is often considered the single most important stat in baseball. It makes sense that the more times you’re on base, the better your chance is of scoring. Pretty common sense stuff. Now even though Markie Mark’s not one the very best ever, he’s still light years ahead of the average player. Many detractors look to his meager lifetime batting average (.263) and use that as reasoning for why he shouldn’t be inducted. Granted, it is definitely a low mark, and well below what should be expected out of a HOF type player, but OBP is a much better reflection of how consistent a hitter McGwire actually was.
Compared to his peers and predecessors, and based on performance and stats alone, there is absolutely no doubt that McGwire should be in the Hall; but a couple of people have had a profound impact on McGwire’s social and historical status. George Mitchell and Jose Canseco apparently think that just because they never played baseball well (even though one of them thinks they did and still can), that nobody ever did, at least not honestly. McGwire has admitted to using andro, a legal supplement, and has not been found guilty of anything else, despite many accusations. The simple fact that he’s come under investigation has turned off baseball purists, who now refuse to allow him into the most holy of holy places, Cooperstown.
The fact remains that we don’t know exactly what happened, with McGwire or anyone, really, and never will. He didn’t break any rules and it certainly isn’t fair to “ex post facto” the rules for him in an attempt to diminish his feats. In a criminal trial, if the defendant is accused but there’s no proof, he’s not going to jail; so why do people try to do that to McGwire? I mean, there’s really no evidence that Big Mac did anything outlandish to increase his physical prowess, is there?
Nobody would buy Wheaties if this little guy was on the box.
This is what McGwire looked like after he had my legs surgically attached to his shoulders.
A lot of people during that period went through a pretty similar transformation (Sammy Sosa, Barry Bonds, me, etc.), so it must be totally normal. We were probably all just going through puberty at the same time. Yeah, that’s it. Puberty.
McGwire’s not likely to make the 75% cut to get voted in this year, after receiving less than 24% last year, but with 12 more years of eligibility after this, hopefully the voters can come to their senses and put this all-time great hitter where he belongs.
No, not jail. The Hall of Fame.
http://www.notfrombristol.com/2009/01/09/mark-mcgwire-hall-of-fame-or-infamy/


Recent Comments